EVICTION

   The Breach of Warranty of Habitability As a Sucker's Bet

 

Tenants have a notion that they can invoke the Breach of Warranty and withhold rent in order to get the apartment repaired. While that is the way the law reads CRPL 235 (b) this is why the individual tenant should never use it:

1. You are withholding rent.

2. At the end of the second month or beginning of the third month the landlord will bring you to Court for non-payment of rent.

3. Let us assume your rent is $1,000 per month so you are now withholding some $3,000 by the third month.

4. Keeping this example simple, let us say you go to trial and prove your Breach of Warranty of Habitability.

5. The judge will now give you an abatement of between 5 and 10 percent.

6. Let us, for this example, say that you recover the 10% abatement which is $300.

7. So the landlord is awarded the $3,000 non-payment less your abatement leading to a net award of $2,700 for the landlord.

  

8. Thus, even though you have won $300 off the rent, the landlord is still recognized as the prevailing party as he goes home with $2,700.

9. But he goes home with much more than that because the prevailing party is also awarded attorney's fees and landlord lawyers easily can charge for 10 hours $3000, so under our most reasonable example the landlord recovers $2,700 plus $3,000 for a total sum of $5,700.

Blogspot

Copyright ©2003 Tenant-AdviceandAlert.com is a free information site of New York Tenant's Rights and Landlord Tenant Law.

Any person who copies the content of this website without the owner's permission, will be prosecuted to the full extent of the law!